|   | 
        
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | Comment on this report, or find other reports. | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | Our Mystery Worshippers are volunteers who warm church pews for us around the world. If you'd like to become a Mystery Worshipper, start here. | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | Find out how to reproduce this report in your church magazine or website. | 
           
                    | 
          | 
        
          
            
                | 2469: National 
                  Shrine of the Little Flower, Royal Oak, Michigan, USA | 
             
            
                | 
             
            
                | 
             
            
                | 
             
            
                 Mystery 
                  Worshipper: Paterfamilias. 
                  The church: 
                  National 
                  Shrine of the Little Flower, Royal Oak, Michigan, USA. 
                  Denomination: 
                  Roman Catholic, 
                  Archdiocese of 
                  Detroit. 
                  The building: 
                  One of the most unusual structures I have encountered. It is 
                  octagonal, with the altar in the very center of the church, 
                  and seating surrounding it on all sides. This is not due to 
                  a renovation after Vatican II; rather, this is the way it was 
                  built in the early 1930s. The altar is of solid Italian marble 
                  and weighs 18 tons. Over the altar is a baldacchino, the top 
                  of which is made of oak, with stained glass underneath the oak 
                  representing the flames of the Holy Spirit. In front of the 
                  church is the Charity Crucifixion Tower, with a 28 foot high 
                  figure of Christ on the cross. The Ku Klux Klan had burned crosses 
                  on the church property in the parish's early days, and this 
                  was intended as a cross they could not burn. This just begins 
                  to describe the richness of the building and grounds, described 
                  on the parish's website. It was declared a national shrine by 
                  the United States Conference of Bishops in 1998. 
                  The church: 
                  The parish began when the then-Archbishop of Detroit, Michael 
                  Gallagher, went to Rome for the canonization of St Therese de 
                  Lisieux (widely known as the Little Flower, hence the church's 
                  name) in 1925, only 28 years after her death at the age of 24. 
                  He was determined to build the first parish in the United States 
                  in St Therese's honor. He chose the charismatic (and later quite 
                  controversial) Father Charles Coughlin as the church's first 
                  pastor. To help fund the building, Father Coughlin undertook 
                  a radio ministry that eventually was attracting an estimated 
                  30 million listeners weekly. However, his vigorously expressed 
                  fascist and antisemitic political views led to the cancellation 
                  (in 1942) of his radio broadcasts and newsletter under threat 
                  of being defrocked and charged with sedition. Coughlin remained 
                  pastor of the Shrine until 1966. Today the parish boasts a membership 
                  of over 4,300 families, with eight weekend masses (one in Spanish) 
                  and two masses each weekday. They support several schools, collectively 
                  providing education from age 3 through high school. There are 
                  the usual social justice, bereavement, and social activities, 
                  and a strong emphasis on Christian formation. 
                  The neighborhood: 
                  Royal Oak is one of Detroit's northern suburbs. In front of 
                  the church is the busy Woodward Avenue, with fast food restaurants, 
                  gas stations, etc. Behind the church can be found middle-class, 
                  single family housing. 
                  The cast: 
                  I am guessing (from photos on the Shrine's website) that the 
                  prayer service was led by the pastor, the Revd Msgr William 
                  Easton, and that the pianist was Greg Grobis. However, there 
                  was no printed bulletin or service leaflet, so no clergy or 
                  musicians were identified. 
                  The date & time: 
                  December 17, 2012, 7.00pm. 
                   
                  What was the name of the 
                  service? 
                  Taizé and Communal Penance Service. 
                   
                  How full was the building? 
                  The building seats 3000, but that includes an extensive balcony. 
                  I will guess 400-450 were in attendance, but given the unusual 
                  design of the church, I'm not sure how accurate my guess is. 
                   
Did anyone welcome you personally? 
No.  There were no ushers.
  
Was your pew comfortable? 
Quite.
  
How would you describe the pre-service
atmosphere? 
Very quiet, as appropriate for a penance service.
  
What were the exact opening words of the
service? 
                  "In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the 
                  Holy Spirit." 
                   
What books did the congregation use during the
service? 
                  Gather Comprehensive, a hardbound hymnal published 
                  in 1994 that is found in many Catholic churches. 
                   
                  What musical instruments 
                  were played? 
                  Piano and violin. There was also a quartet of singers. Music 
                  texts were projected onto two large screens, in front of the 
                  balcony on either side of the altar. 
                   
                  Did anything distract 
                  you? 
                  I had expected a typical Taizé service, but I realized 
                  after it began that the Taizé chanting would come later, 
                  as the service was to be primarily an opportunity for everyone 
                  to make their private confession to one of the 16 or 17 priests 
                  who were present. I actually thought about leaving (this Lutheran 
                  would not be so brazen as to ask a Catholic priest for absolution). 
                  But I stayed, and ultimately was glad that I did.
  
 
  
Was the worship stiff-upper-lip, 
                  happy clappy, or what? 
                  It was a formal liturgy, but only as a prelude to private confession. 
                  It lasted about 25 minutes and opened with a prayer, followed 
                  by scriptural readings, a brief homily, an examination of conscience, 
                  and a litany. The Taizé part of the service began as 
                  congregants lined up for their confessions. The six musicians 
                  began singing and playing the simple refrains and ostinati from 
                  the Taizé tradition, and a few of us in the congregation 
                  joined with them quietly. The singing continued in this vein 
                  for a bit more than an hour. 
                   
                  Exactly how long was the 
                  sermon? 
                  As I had never experienced preaching in a Taizé service 
                  before, I did not bring my watch, but I would estimate 6 to 
                  7 minutes. 
                   
                  On a scale of 1-10, how 
                  good was the preacher? 
                  8  The pastor was very low key but an effective speaker. 
                  He moved around a bit, as he was surrounded by congregation 
                  on all sides. 
                   
                  In a nutshell, what was 
                  the sermon about? 
                  He began by noting the school massacre in Connecticut that had 
                  happened only three days earlier. He said that while the murders 
                  might show us to be a sinful and more godless society, we cannot 
                  point fingers at others  we are here this evening to confess 
                  our own sins. We must ask God to strengthen us, so that this 
                  Christmas his coming will be more concrete, more real. 
                   
                  Which part of the service 
                  was like being in heaven? 
                  Singers, pianist, and violinist were superb; they obviously 
                  have experience with Taizé. Everything was very reverent, 
                  very peaceful. The pianist's improvisations between different 
                  refrains were restrained, yet beautiful in their simplicity. 
                   
                  And which part was like 
                  being in... er... the other place? 
As I noted above, I was expecting something a bit different; I felt more than a little out of place at an evening where private confession was the primary event.  But ultimately I'm glad I remained.
  
What happened when you hung around after the service looking lost? 
                  Once individuals had made their confession, they either left 
                  or came back to their pew and joined in the singing. But by 
                  the time I left, there were very few congregants remaining, 
                  and all left quietly. 
                   
How would you describe the after-service
coffee? 
There was none.
  
                  How would you feel about 
                  making this church your regular (where 10 = ecstatic, 0 = terminal)? 
                  5  I think I'll remain Lutheran. But I would love to go 
                  back to a Taizé service there that is not in a penitential 
                  season, especially if these wonderful musicians were going to 
                  be present. 
                   
                  Did the service make you 
                  feel glad to be a Christian? 
Yes.
  
What one thing will you remember about all this in seven days' time? 
                  As I drove home, I could not help but think about the Connecticut 
                  parents who had buried their children earlier in the day. As 
                  the father of two, I could not imagine what it would be like 
                  for a parent to go through such a service. I found the songs 
                  we sang so appropriate ("Our darkness is never darkness; in 
                  your sight the deepest night is clear as the daylight") at this 
                  time of our national trauma. I'm glad I didn't leave. | 
             
           
         | 
          | 
        
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | We rely on voluntary donations to stay online. If you're a regular visitor to Ship of Fools, please consider supporting us. | 
           
          
          
          
              | 
           
          
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | The Mystery Pilgrim | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            |  One of our most seasoned reporters makes the Camino pilgrimage to Santiago de Compostela in Spain. Read here. | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | London churches | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            |  Read reports from 70 London churches, visited by a small army of Mystery Worshippers on one single Sunday. Read here.  | 
           
          
            |   | 
           
          
          | 
          | 
         | 
          |