|   | 
        
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | Comment on this report, or find other reports. | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | Our Mystery Worshippers are volunteers who warm church pews for us around the world. If you'd like to become a Mystery Worshipper, start here. | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | Find out how to reproduce this report in your church magazine or website. | 
           
                    | 
          | 
        1196: St Mary the Virgin, Times Square, New York City, USA
  
 
  
Mystery Worshipper: Fishngrl. 
      The church: St Mary the Virgin, Times Square, New York City, USA. 
      Denomination: Episcopal Church in the USA. 
The building: St Mary's dates from 1895 and was the first church 
      anywhere in the world to be constructed on a steel frame. Its elegant French 
      Gothic design is masked on the exterior by neighboring buildings but is 
      strikingly apparent on the inside. The interior was extensively cleaned 
      and restored in 1997. The ceiling is painted blue with golden stars, and 
      the sanctuary features an east-facing marble altar. The nave is a delight 
      to behold, with its many glorious frescoes and icons, an elegant baptistery, 
      and numerous side chapels. And the acoustics are perfect! This is a must-see 
      church! 
      The church: Fondly but irreverently known as Smoky Mary's, 
      this church strives to be a witness to the Catholic Christian tradition 
      within the Anglican Church. Its music program includes the very best of 
      liturgical works throughout the centuries. The divine office is recited 
      each weekday in the morning, noon and evening, and mass is offered daily 
      at 12.10pm. Weekend services include a Saturday evening vigil mass, three 
      Sunday masses, and solemn evensong and benediction on Sunday evening. 
      The neighborhood: Snuggled in the middle of West 46th Street just 
      off Times Square, and within a thurible's swing of the theater district, 
      St Mary's is located in arguably one of the most bustling commercial and 
      tourist areas anywhere in the world.  
      The cast: The Rev. John Beddingfield, curate, was the celebrant, 
      assisted by the Rev. Matthew Mead, curate, and the Rev. James Ross Smith, 
      assisting priest. About 14 acolytes, including a crucifer and thurifer, 
      rounded out the altar party. Imagine the procession! 
      The date & time: March 1, 2006 (Ash Wednesday), 6.00pm. 
  
What was the name of the service? 
      Ash Wednesday Solemn High Mass. 
       
How full was the building? 
      Not quite one-half full. The church later posted on their website that 617 people attended the service. 
       
Did anyone welcome you personally? 
      Yes. An usher said, "If you're here for ashes, just go on up. Are you staying 
      for the mass? Good! The music will be wonderful." Whereupon he handed me 
      a service leaflet. After I had settled in, I noticed that this same usher 
      was checking on people who were already seated to ensure that they had bulletins. 
      A very friendly greeting, and the exchange of peace later on was friendly 
      also. 
       
Was your pew comfortable? 
      The unpadded pew was fairly comfortable and the angle of the pew back was 
      not overly severe. Kneelers were the old-style, barely-padded faux leather 
      type. Being short, I have difficulty kneeling in this kind of pew as the 
      backs of the pews are too tall. 
       
How would you describe the pre-service
atmosphere? 
      I arrived about 15 minutes before the service began, and dozens of people 
      were drifting in to pray at various side altars, light candles, or receive 
      ashes. The atmosphere was prayerful and reverent. Service participants, including 
      priests and acolytes, were busy making last-minute preparations, but they 
      took their roles seriously, reverencing the altar properly each time they 
      passed it. A young girl acolyte was being coached on where to stand at the 
      altar before the gospel procession; it turned out that she was the crucifer 
      as well as the bearer of the book. 
       
What were the exact opening words of the
service? 
"The angel of the Lord announced unto Mary, and she conceived by the Holy Spirit," and into the Angelus we went.
  
What books did the congregation use during the
service? 
      Everything, including service music and liturgical chant, was printed on 
      a well-prepared service leaflet. The liturgy came from the 1979 Book 
      of Common Prayer and hymns from the 1982 Hymnal. 
       
What musical instruments were played? 
      A grand Aeolian-Skinner pipe organ, that company's opus 891. 
       
Did anything distract you? 
      It was easy to be distracted, in the best way, by the reverence of both 
      the service participants and the congregation, the beauty of the worship 
      space, and the sound of the marvelous liturgy as sung by the choir. A baby 
      cried at times, which was hardly troublesome compared to the cell phone 
      that began to chirp as the celebrant said, "He stretched out his arms upon 
      the cross..." 
       
Was the worship stiff-upper-lip, happy clappy, or
what? 
      Spikily Anglo-Catholic and as high up the candle as one can go (or at least 
      as this Episcopalian has experienced). The church is called Smoky Mary's 
      for good reason. Plumes of smoke wafted toward the ceiling and throughout 
      the nave. The priests faced the altar rather than the congregation, and 
      almost everyone kneeled for the eucharistic prayer. Wonderfully Anglo-Catholic 
      but not stuffy at all. 
       
Exactly how long was the sermon? 
      6 minutes. 
       
On a scale of 1-10, how good was the preacher? 
      9  Father Beddingfield preached a warm, concise, on-target sermon 
      completely without notes.  
       
In a nutshell, what was the sermon
about? 
      He spoke on the theme of ashes cleansing us of our sins, and used a story 
      from Marilynne Robinson's novel Gilead to illustrate his point 
      about how there could be nothing cleaner than ashes to prepare us for God's 
      forgiveness. 
       
Which part of the service was like being in
heaven? 
      Just about every bit of the service was heavenly. While some might think 
      of Anglo-Catholicism as being formal and stuffy, rather than approachable 
      liturgy, that's not how it is here. One moment especially stood out for 
      me: During the gospel procession, the young girl who bore the book opened 
      it up and placed the spine on her forehead, holding it steady at just the 
      right height and angle for Father Mead to chant the Word. It was a beautiful 
      gesture, and the warm look of approbation Father gave her for doing so well 
      was just priceless.  
       
And which part was like being in... er... the other place? 
      This is a large, high-ceilinged gothic church, probably very expensive to 
      heat and impossible to keep adequately warm. I had visited before and had 
      been cold during the service, so this time I came prepared, wearing longjohns 
      and a sweater... And that cell phone going off during the eucharistic prayer 
      was inexcusable, although it was silenced pretty fast. 
       
What happened when you hung around after the service looking lost? 
      Father Beddingfield asked me my name and engaged me in small talk for a 
      moment or two. Several people nodded hello. 
       
How would you describe the after-service
coffee? 
Coffee hour would not have been appropriate after an Ash Wednesday service, and there was none.
  
How would you feel about making this church your regular (where 10 = ecstatic, 0 = terminal)? 
      9  I've visited here a couple of times in the past few months and 
      have been very warmly welcomed each time. The priests and congregation are 
      genuinely friendly, the congregation is diverse in terms of race, age, etc. 
       this could easily be my church home.  
       
Did the service make you feel glad to be a
Christian? 
      Very much so. I'm looking forward to visiting throughout Lent. 
       
What one thing will you remember about all this in seven days' time? 
      The girl holding the gospel book on her forehead and the priest's approving 
      smile. Every acolyte should be trained so well! | 
          | 
        
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | We rely on voluntary donations to stay online. If you're a regular visitor to Ship of Fools, please consider supporting us. | 
           
          
          
          
              | 
           
          
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | The Mystery Pilgrim | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            |  One of our most seasoned reporters makes the Camino pilgrimage to Santiago de Compostela in Spain. Read here. | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            | London churches | 
           
          
              | 
           
          
            |  Read reports from 70 London churches, visited by a small army of Mystery Worshippers on one single Sunday. Read here.  | 
           
          
            |   | 
           
          
          | 
          | 
         | 
          |